
I've been thinking about the current and future states of learning a lot lately. Specifically, I'm exploring face-to-face classroom instruction vs. live virtual classrooms. My focus is on corporate learning, since that's what my experience is.
In the spirit of provoking thought and discussion, here are three reasons why "traditional" physical classroom offerings don't meet the need in corporate learning anymore:
1. Location, location, location...
In our flat world during this information age, it is a rare luxury when the expert trainer and his/her learners live and work in the same city. As a result, some travel is typically required to bring the group together for a face-to-face class.
Best case, the instructor travels to meet a group of co-located students. While this is the least costly scenario, it can be a fast path to personal or professional burnout for our traveling trainer. (I've met more than one road warrior who sacrificed his marriage to the job...) Similarly, many qualified instructors refuse to go "full-time" and travel every week for various personal reasons (including possible divorce). So the cost isn't just the travel time and dollars spent; there's an opportunity cost of untapped talent as well.
It's bad when the instructor flies to meet his class. But it's far worse when the group is distributed, and THEY all need to travel to congregate in one place. Typically "distributed" means spread across multiple states in the same country, or neighboring countries in a region. This is often the threshold of cost/benefit tradeoffs and actually funding such a class. When the group is truly global, travel costs quickly spiral out of control and such offerings
are almost unheard of.
are almost unheard of.
In the best case, differing locations of the instructor and/or students can make learning inconvenient and expensive. The worst case is that it prohibits the offering from being funded and scheduled at all, and the learning just doesn't happen!
2. Time is of the essence!
Let's use an example where a group in Chicago needs training only available from a specialist in San Francisco. So the instructor gets on a plane and meets his class in the Windy City. Let's also say there are 12 hours of material to cover. This will inevitably be scheduled as a 2-day class. They may be two evenly paced days, 6 hours each, with comfortable breaks throughout. Or more likely, it is one grueling 8-hour day and one 4-hour day. After all, the instructor wants to catch an afternoon flight to get home earlier. Plus, the group doesn't really want to pay for an extra night at the hotel.
This all sounds pretty typical, right? And what's wrong with this picture -- we do this sort of thing all the time... The problem is it didn't give any consideration to the best way for the learners to absorb/digest/retain those 12 hours of material! If you ever attended a 3-hour lecture in college, how long were you actively engaged before you zoned out? And what if you learn by repetition, reviewing material on your own in between lectures? Or what about the concepts of homework and practice, then reviewing your questions with the teacher?
When travel is involved, limited education budgets necessarily schedule full days. But if you can't soak up all the good stuff in a jam-packed whirlwind class, you may as well stay home.
3. It's all Greek (or Hebrew? or Mandarin? or Hindi?) to me.
When a facilitator asks a question to gauge interest or understanding, she relies on responses from the class. Indeed, this is a best practice in avoiding lecture boredom to keep an audience engaged and actively learning. The verbal communication is quite natural when the group is all fluent in the same language.
But back to our flat world, it's quite likely a diverse group won't share a common native language. Accordingly, they will have varying spoken language skills. Non-native language speakers may be much slower to respond, if they participate at all. (I've experienced this with Chinese and Japanese engineers who wrote impeccably but struggled with spoken English.)
Bottom line...
Traditional classroom learning originated in a time when life was simpler. There was a smaller information base in the world, and knowledge was more general. Travel to bring together disjoint groups was either unecessary, unfeasible, or downright impossible. Travel aside, no other technology existed to connect people effectively without significant delay. So face-to-face classrooms were the natural and best solution to address educational needs.
Today's world is constantly changing, driving the need for continuous learning. We live in a global economy, interacting with people from around the world. Even our localized exchanges are with people from diverse backgrounds. Most people have traveled to nearby states, neighboring countries, and perhaps overseas locales. Many nontravellers find themselves connected to people through the telephone, internet, and various related technologies.
Traditional classrooms just aren't suited to meet the learning demands our corporations face today. The good news is that there are tools, techniques, and techologies that are fit for the challenge. But that is material for another blog post...
No comments:
Post a Comment